Interested in a little light reading?

Color is a critical quality component for spices like paprika. The American Spice Trade Association (ASTA) has sampling and measurement standards for paprika, and a spectrophotometer from HunterLab effectively quantifies paprika color values for quality assurance.

How Paprika and Oleoresin Spices Are Made

Paprika is obtained from the ripened, ground, and dried fruit pods of the Capsicum annuum species. The Capsicum annuum peppers used for paprika are sweet and mild with little to no capsaicin, which is a heat compound.

The Capsicum annuum plant is grown until its peppers are mature and have ripened to a red color. The fully ripened peppers are picked for paprika to give the spice its signature red color. The pepper seeds are removed, and the fruit pods are dried in the sun or specially constructed dryers. After drying, producers grind peppers into powder.

Oleoresin paprika — or paprika extract — is the oil-soluble extract obtained by extracting lipids and pigments from Capsicum annuum Linn or Capsicum frutescens fruits. The oleoresin comprises capsaicin, capsanthin, and capsorubin, giving the product a strong taste and odor. Oleoresin paprika is a natural dye that colors foods a deep red color.

For those who love the sweeter things in life, cocoa powder is a must-have pantry staple. Whether it's a necessary ingredient in baking or a finishing touch on the sweetest confections, many people buy cocoa powder at some point in their lives. Therefore, they know what it's meant to look like.

Though cocoa powder can come in a range of shades, anything too out of the ordinary may be perceived as low quality or expired, driving consumers to new brands to find their next container. Measuring the color of your cocoa powder helps maintain quality assurance and keeps your processes running as they should.

What Causes Differences in Cocoa Powder Color?

Most shoppers buy the cheapest or best-looking box of cocoa powder on the shelves, but as someone involved with the product, you should know more about what goes into every box. The three types of cocoa powder each offer a darker, richer color than the one before:

1. Natural: Cocoa beans are simply fermented, dried, roasted, and ground, creating a strong flavor and acidic powder. Most products on store shelves are this type, meaning customers are familiar with the light brown color.
2. Dutch process: This product comes from beans washed in potassium carbonate. The alkaline solution neutralizes the acidity, influencing how it functions in recipes. This alkalizing process also darkens the powder.
3. Black: As the name implies, this powder is almost black. Its deep shade comes from treatment with a stronger alkalizing agent.

Besides color differences between types of cocoa powder, other factors during the production process influence appearance. The cocoa beans that produce each powder have varying levels of acidity, fermentation time, and other factors — all of which impact the appearance of the final result. 

Even after production, the look changes. The powder color may degrade during storage due to light, heat, and humidity influences. Identifying differences can support better quality control processes, from production to storage.

Though some of the color differences are not obvious to the human eye, they can affect quality and even taste over time. That is why it is necessary to compare samples and measure results using color measurement equipment like a spectrophotometer from HunterLab.

Measuring the color of tomatoes is an essential step for identifying the ripeness, quality, and salability of the product for consumption. The tomato's color is an indicator of its maturity and plays a crucial role in determining the flavor and texture of the fruit.

Understanding the color of tomatoes can help producers, distributors, and retailers ensure they provide their customers with the best possible product. Consistently meet quality standards by verifying the desired tomato color before shipping, processing, or selling the product.

The Case for Tomato Color Measurement

Tomatoes change color as they ripen, and different stages of ripeness are associated with different colors. Unripe tomatoes are green, and the fruit will become yellow, orange, or red as it grows and ripens, depending on the variety. A tomato's color can provide insight into its freshness as well. Tomatoes that are picked too early or have been improperly stored may be pale in color. Natural variation will occur, but fresh tomatoes should have a vibrant, mostly uniform color.

In addition to determining ripeness, the color of a tomato can also indicate its nutritional content. Red tomatoes are high in lycopene, an antioxidant that is associated with a reduced risk of heart disease and certain types of cancer. By measuring the color of tomatoes, producers and distributors can ensure that they provide their customers with the most nutritious product possible.

Spices provide culinary flavor and visual appeal, and their color significantly influences perceptions of taste, quality, and freshness. Appearance alterations can identify processes that require changes to uphold color quality. Accurate spice color measurement provides quantifiable data to confirm whether spices meet accepted industry tolerances, quality standards, and customer expectations.

The Value of Accurate Spice Color Analysis

Several compelling reasons to measure spice color are:

• Quality control: Consumers judge food quality by color, and high moisture content, temperature fluctuations during storage, and spice age significantly impact appearance. Quantifying and monitoring the color quality of spices supports higher-quality end products.
• Business impact: People also expect certain spice colors to enhance food's visual appeal. Consistently delivering the desired color fosters brand loyalty and can create lifelong brand enthusiasts.
• Conformance with standards: Some spices, such as paprika and oleoresin spices, have specific industry standards they may follow. Other spices use different industry-recognized color spaces, like Hunter L, a, b. Accurate measurements document conformance with frameworks.

Integrating Measurements Throughout Manufacturing

Taking multiple measurements allows manufacturers to monitor the color quality at critical production points, simplifying issue identification and empowering early resolution to reduce waste. Quantifying data at various stages also pinpoints where color alterations occur so you can proactively adjust. Consider implementing color measurement across production, from raw material inspections to in-process color data capture and finished product verification.

Sample Considerations for Spice Manufacturers

Spices come with unique color measurement challenges, including:

Sample Size vs. Cost

Sample size may not concern those working with low-cost spices like black pepper, but quantifying color in high-cost spices like saffron represents a more significant expense. Manufacturers of these more costly spices benefit from minimizing the sample amount required. A highly precise and accurate color measurement solution supports greater confidence in outcomes, even with smaller samples. The right tool also means less waste of valuable ingredients, so more goes toward retail shelves and your bottom line.

Nonuniform Materials

Spices are naturally nonuniform, containing various textures, sizes, and shapes from their processed plant parts. Blends like seasoning salt or curry powder further increase complexity with a mix of different spice ingredients. These variations make visual comparisons unreliable and accurate data capture challenging without the right technology.

“Spectrometer” is a general term for any instrument that measures how electromagnetic radiation interacts with matter. A spectrophotometer is a specific type of spectrometer designed to measure how much light is reflected or transmitted by a sample across a range of wavelengths representing typical human vision. Both are critical quality assurance equipment in many industries, yet each has its distinct purposes and ideal applications. Exploring their traits and differences will help you determine which option best meets your unique business demands.

What Are Spectrometers?

This equipment quantifies the electromagnetic radiation within specific wavelengths of a sample.

Modern spectrometer types include the following:

• Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometers that help biochemists evaluate the properties of organic molecules
• Optical spectrometers that measure the intensity of light at different wavelengths to analyze the optical properties of a sample
• Mass spectrometers that analyze a sample's molecular mass to help identify its molecular composition

Benefits of Spectrometers

Advantages of spectrometers include:

• Sensitivity: These advanced solutions can detect even trace amounts of many elements and compounds and minute variations within samples.
• Versatility: Spectrometers can quantify spectra from liquids, solids, and gases.
• Wide spectrum: Optical spectrometers can measure and quantify wavelengths beyond the visible spectrum, such as ultraviolet rays and infrared light.

Ideal Applications for Spectrometers

These solutions are essential in many industries and applications, such as:

• Life sciences
• Criminal forensics
• Material characterization
• Pollution monitoring
• Space exploration
• Water quality
• Agricultural analysis

Light and color measurement processes use many types of equipment — radiometers, spectrometers, spectroradiometers, and spectrophotometers. While all four solutions are used to measure electromagnetic energy, they vary widely in their capabilities, applications, and intended purposes. It’s important to know and understand the differences between these solutions to determine which one will adequately serve your needs.

Radiometer vs. Spectrometer vs. Spectroradiometer vs. Spectrophotometer

These devices have similar names and are used to measure spectral data points and wavelengths within the electromagnetic spectrum. Despite this similarity, they have varying scopes regarding the types and qualities of measurements they produce.

Radiometers can only detect and measure electromagnetic radiation within a particular wavelength range. Spectrometers measure a broader scale of electromagnetic energy and have more capabilities, including breaking down signals based on amplitude. Spectrometers are a larger category under which other devices like spectroradiometers and spectrophotometers fall. 

In comparing spectroradiometers vs. spectrometers, the main difference is that spectroradiometers combine the capabilities of radiometers and spectrometers. These devices also collect details about power, radiance, and other metrics.

Spectrophotometers measure the amplitude of light reflected or transmitted by a sample, which can then be used to calculate the exact color. Unlike the other tools, spectrophotometers focus on how transmitted and reflected light generates color rather than on the qualities of the light itself.

What Is a Radiometer?

A radiometer measures the electromagnetic energy present in a specific wavelength range. This solution is typically used to detect and quantify energy outside the visible light spectrum and measure infrared and ultraviolet light. The radiometer begins by measuring the incoming current or voltage in watts, then corrects the signal to create a calibrated, quantitative light level measurement. With this information, the meter provides one reading over the specific wavelength range it is designed to measure.

Pros and Cons of Radiometers

Radiometers are inexpensive and portable, making them a cost-effective and practical choice. This solution can identify troublesome UV energy and detect and measure heat energy on surfaces. It also has one sensor that allows it to quickly measure all intended wavelengths.

However, radiometers cannot identify emitted wavelengths or their individual amplitude. Sometimes, variations exist in the filter used to match the light source, which creates difficulty when comparing results from radiometers of different manufacturers. Also, radiometers only measure a particular range of wavelengths, unlike other tools. 

Applications

Radiometers' ability to detect the presence of UV energy makes them valuable tools for any application where it is undesirable, such as museum lighting. In this atmosphere, UV energy could degrade artifacts or artwork.

The device also measures infrared light, enabling surface temperature measurements in settings such as along an assembly line or on a road's surface. Other applications include monitoring weather, like precipitation and wind speeds.

Color tolerances set acceptable limits for the appearance of a product and are an essential part of quality assurance and quality control processes for color. You can efficiently determine whether a product falls within the limits by establishing tolerances. If it does, the product passes. Failed goods fall outside the tolerances, meaning process adjustments may be necessary to create the desired appearance. 

Many industries, such as food, plastics, and chemicals, rely on accurate appearance. Tolerances enable you to establish a standard and decide how much variation to allow, giving you consistent color outcomes. 

What Is Color Tolerance?

Color tolerances are the parameters within which a product's color can vary yet remain acceptable. Typically, visual assessment is the initial step to define the acceptable color range. Spectrophotometry then objectively and scientifically quantifies and manages those tolerances.

Before establishing tolerance values, you must decide on the observer, choose a color scale, such as Hunter L,a,b, and then select illuminants for comparison, like D 65 and Illuminant A. Depending on what you're measuring, the scale you choose might come from the International Commission on Illumination (CIE), which sets global measurement standards, or from another entity. 

Once you have a comparison standard, you can gather products and measure their color to determine acceptable variations called tolerance values. 

In this process, you start by selecting a relevant standard for your product, then determine how much this standard can vary before it creates visible differences in appearance. This test helps you set boundaries for future production to objectively decide whether products fall close enough to the original standard to conform to quality expectations.

Detecting Color Differences

You can establish tolerances based on two levels of difference:

• Minimum perceptible difference: A visual comparison shows a just-noticeable difference between the standard and the sample. 
• Maximum acceptable difference: The level represents the largest acceptable difference between a standard and a sample. 

Focusing on the maximum acceptable difference means a broader range of acceptable values, while relying solely on minimum perceptible difference can lead to high rejection and material waste. As a result, choosing the right approach is typically industry-driven. For example, the food industry frequently uses the maximum acceptable difference, but pharmaceutical manufacturers usually opt for the minimum perceptible difference.

Range of Tolerance Definition

The range of tolerance is the acceptable level of variation related to an established color standard. You will establish this standard using a measurement model like CIE L*a*b*, which results in three values measuring:

• L*: Lightness, from dark at zero to light at 100.
• a*: Position on the red–green axis, with the positive number indicating red and the negative indicating green.
• b*: Position on the yellow–blue axis, with yellow represented as the positive and blue as the negative.

Once you establish a standard, you can decide on each dimension's tolerance. Here are the formulas for determining the difference (∆) between a sample and a reference:

∆L* = L*sample - L*reference

∆a* = a*sample - a*reference

∆b* = b*sample - b*reference

You can also calculate the total color difference across the three values in a single formula, with the results represented by delta E* (∆E*). Here's the formula to determine ∆E*:

∆E* = √((∆L*)2+(∆a*)2+(∆b*)2)

While ∆E* values can be helpful, use this method carefully. When the difference is spread over three dimensions, you may get a value that looks acceptable but has significant variation in one measurement, such as red vs. green. 

This variation will create a noticeable visual difference but may not impact the delta E* value if the other dimensions are close to the standard. If you calculate the difference values separately, you can more closely monitor each one to verify that none stray too far from the standard.